332: Rethinking “Following Directions” Goals in Speech Therapy

Show Notes:

In this episode of SLP Coffee Talk, Hallie chats with Emily Byers Chaney—pediatric SLP, private practice owner, and neurodiversity affirming advocate—about why following directions goals might not be telling you what you think they are. Emily shares how working alongside Jessie Ginsburg shifted her entire clinical lens, what’s really happening when a child doesn’t follow a direction, and how to build therapy that’s meaningful, motivating, and actually carries over. This one’s for every SLP who’s ever wondered if there’s a better way to work on receptive language.

Join me for FREE CF Bootcamp on Wednesday, July 1st, 2–3 PM ET.

Here’s what we learned:

  • Comprehension ≠ compliance. A child can understand and still not follow through.
  • Connection first. Safety and relationship aren’t a detour—they’re the work.
  • Go beyond the assessment. Play-based observation reveals what standardized testing misses.
  • Watch for overcompliance. Too much compliance-focused therapy can erode autonomy and self-advocacy.
  • One small shift. You don’t have to overhaul everything—just start somewhere.

RESOURCES

🎤✨ The Speech Retreat is Back! Learn more and register here!
https://www.speechretreat.com

🎉FREE CF Bootcamp on July 1st from 2:00 PM–3:00 PM!
https://speechtimefun.com/cfbootcamp2026

📘✨ Grab your copy of The Secondary SLP Roadmap here! https://www.speechtimefunpd.com/stf-book 

Learn more about Hallie Sherman  and SLP Elevate: 

Learn more about Emily Byers Chaney: 

JOKE OF THE WEEK:

Q: Why couldn’t the duck pay for dinner?

A: Because her bill was too big.

Where We Can Connect: 

Subscribe & Review on Apple Podcasts

Are you subscribed to the podcast? If you’re not, I want to encourage you to subscribe today so you don’t miss any future episodes! I already have so many amazing guests and topics lined up, I would hate for you to miss a single one!  Click here to subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

Could I ask a big favor? If you are loving the podcast, I would LOVE it if you would leave me a review on Apple Podcasts. I read each and every review.  Plus, you get to pay it forward because it will allow other teachers like you to find the podcast! Wondering how to leave a review? Click here to review, then select “Ratings and Reviews” and “Write a Review”.  So easy and so appreciated! 

Do you have a question you would like me to answer on the podcast?

GREAT! CLICK HERE TO FILL OUT THE FORM! 

TRANSCRIPT

00:00:00 Hallie: Quick break, SLPs. The Speech Retreat is back. It’s the virtual professional development event that is actually fun. Think about it. Raffles, laughs, a virtual photo booth, and real-world ideas that you can use the very next day for preschool through high school. Six different speakers that actually get it and are talking about topics that are relevant to you. Earn CEU’s live, join PDH’s on replays, and connect with a community of SLPs who love what they do. Don’t miss it. Learn about the next event, the date, the speakers, and more at the speechretreat.com. 

00:00:46 Hallie: Welcome to SLP Coffee Talk, the podcast designed exclusively for speech language pathologists who work with older students, grades 4 through 12. I am your host, Hallie Sherman, your SLP behind Speech Time Fun, the Speech Retreat Conference, and the SLP Elevate Membership. And I’m thrilled to bring you conversations, strategies, and insights that will give you the jolt of inspiration that you need. Whether you’re tuning in during your morning commute, on a break in between sessions, or even during a well-deserved relaxation time. I am here for you each and every week. Let’s do this SLPs.

00:01:26 Hallie: Hey, hey, and welcome to another episode of SLP Coffee Talk. I hear a lot of SLPs asking about fun directions activities and how to approach them. And I know you’re going to love this conversation we’re going to have here today with SLP. Emily Byers Chaney, welcome to the show. 

00:01:44 Emily: Hello. Thank you so much for having me. It’s an honor to be here. 

00:01:48 Hallie: Tell everyone listening a little bit about yourself and your SLP journey to what you are doing now. 

00:01:53 Emily: So I have been a pediatric SLP for eight years now, and I just opened my own private practice called Family Speech and Language. I live in Los Angeles and just over the years, I’ve gotten very passionate about neurodiversity affirming practices and really integrating that into the way I work with kids and the way that I support families. And I’m also passionate about sharing all about what I’m learning online. And I’m really always learning and I just am really thankful to be in this job. It’s the best career in life.

00:02:30 Hallie: I love it. And I discovered you from the neurodiversity affirming practices, you know, chats in the world. How did you become so passionate? Like, how did you dive deeper into that expertise? 

00:02:43 Emily: Good question. So I actually worked with Jessie Ginsburg at her clinic and she really opened my eyes to just learning about it. And this is kind of relatively new, right? Like when I started, we both didn’t know much about it at all. And I really wasn’t told about it in my graduate school education. And so we both really learned a lot over the last years and we were able to learn together. And from initially learning from her, I’ve really tried to listen to neurodivergent voices and I’ve just dived really deeply into trying to listen to them and what they’re trying to tell us as the professionals working with these kiddos.

00:03:30 Hallie: So I bet you can relate that… I think I’m older than Jessie. So I clearly also did not learn about this in graduate school and it’s very new and eye opening to me. And I always felt in the schools that only the SLPs really knew about this.

00:03:46 Emily: Yeah, it’s very new. Well, not new. People have been neurodivergent –

00:03:51 Hallie: Talking about it more and more is newer. 

00:03:53 Emily: Yeah, yeah. And so the weirdness is really getting out there and it’s this paradigm shift. I call it the neurodiversity paradigm shift and it’s really wonderful to see happening. And I’ve had to change a lot of what I’ve done. You know, I always say, when you know better, you do better, but there’s things… new, important pieces of information I learned probably every week. So I think that’s just an important piece of our job is to remain open to always learn. 

00:04:26 Hallie: I love that. And what have you learned about connection over compliance? 

00:04:31 Emily: Yes. So this is one of my core values. We are so focused and taught, I think, about data. And I hear you talking about data collection too. And it’s because it’s so… we are told, you know, lesson plan, collect the data, and it is important. But I think that can pull us away from what’s really important, which is our relationship with the student, the client in front of us. And I found that if we’re too focused on compliance, we lose sight of what we’re really targeting, right? And that ties into the topic today with receptive language goals. Are we targeting whether the person understands what we’re saying or whether they’ll carry out the direction, whether they’ll do what we’re trying to tell them to do?

00:05:25 Emily: So shifting that has been so important to me. It’s just remembering that connection is more important than compliance. I speak a lot about compliance-based therapy and wanting to move away from that, especially in the neurodiversity affirming lens. It’s just so important to focus on helping a child feel safe, feel heard, understood, and build that relationship first. 

00:05:50 Hallie: And for someone listening who might be new to this realm, so what is the difference between neurodiversity affirming practices and what is compliance practices? What does that mean? 

00:05:59 Emily: Good question. So compliance-based therapy might be rooted in behaviorism, and neurodiversity affirming therapy is more child-led, I would say is a really good way to explain it. It means you’re supporting the way a child’s brain naturally works rather than trying to make them appear more typically. And it’s focusing on communication, autonomy, and meaningful participation in ways that feel safe, respectful, and motivating to them, not just maybe society. So an example of this is stimming, right? Stimming might look different to a neurotypical person. But for a neurodivergent person, this is really important to them and their regulations. So it’s about understanding that rather than trying to change it. And that’s just a small example. 

00:06:52 Hallie: And I know working in a school, so often administrators and parents want the children, the students to appear neurotypical and we want them to sit at a desk and do a worksheet and do reading and look like a neurotypical student and they have to work towards their sensory breaks and things like that. And how is this approach different than that?

00:07:17 Emily: So it’s nuanced and I want to say that upfront because in my practice, I have the freedom and the flexibility to run around the room and go on the swing and jump around. So I do want to say that in certain settings, right, and it’s setting-specific and it’s child-specific, there are academic settings where that is an important skill and it’s an important way to participate meaningfully in the day. But the difference is just shifting the mindset and finding little ways, even in your setting of supporting those underlying needs because if those underlying needs aren’t understood and aren’t supported, then we’re missing out on so much. And we might just be targeting something that is kind of a band aid over a big wound. And there might be a lot going on that we really need to understand how to support even in the academic setting. 

00:08:22 Hallie: I love that. So how is following direction, how often is it not an accurate measure of true comprehension? 

00:08:30 Emily: Yes, good question. So I personally don’t target following direction goals very much. I do understand that assessments, standardized assessments, those are necessary and they’re necessary for me to use sometimes too with accessing funding and all of that. But it’s often really difficult to quantify receptive language skills. So this is where a comprehensive evaluation is really important. So pairing that standardized assessment with describing what a child understands and how you might be seeing that. What’s tricky about all of this is that there’s so many other skills that are involved in following a direction and not only skills, but regulation. 

00:09:20 Emily: So if a child is dysregulated or… and that could be emotional regulation or sensory regulation, they might understand what’s being asked of them, but following through on that task is really challenging. And also there’s this executive functioning skills that play a part. So that’s the difference between receptive language and following through with a task. And we want to find out where the breakdown is. Is it really the understanding the language or is there some sort of need that’s not being met that’s preventing the child from maybe pointing to this picture and the best picture, right? 

00:10:03 Hallie: So how do you discover that? Like, what would you recommend if someone’s like, how do I know?

00:10:08 Emily: Yeah. So oftentimes I do need to use a standardized assessment so I might see what happens there first. And if there’s a breakdown, then maybe just do some child-led play, see what’s happening during play, right? Because there’s a lot of these concepts in our daily life and there’s a lot of these concepts in play. So they may not have been able to point to the black star and then the… 

00:10:38 Hallie: [inaudible]

00:10:40 Emily: But in play, wow, this child was able to demonstrate that before we go to sleep, the doll is going to brush their teeth. Or these concepts, you just… take some more detective work. But if you’re able to separate from that standardized assessment and actually see, make some observations during play, or even involving the student’s special interests, especially, right, you can see, oh, my goodness, there is this understanding of these concepts in these contexts. And then you can build your goals and therapy from there. And it’s a lot more meaningful that way, too. 

00:11:18 Hallie: And let’s just say they are struggling in those contexts, then you will address them in those contexts and not in that isolated, irrelevant structure. 

00:11:26 Emily: 100%. And I’ve found… because I did write these goals, right? And I found that they often don’t carry over to the other context. So that’s exactly right. It’s about finding what’s functional and meaningful and working on that still within that context. 

00:11:46 Hallie: [inaudible] I love it. Like you mean more than just that [inaudible]. I love that you even just said, though, I get it. Sometimes we need to do it. But that’s not the… we can’t be married to those responses only and say, okay, now they can’t do it. I need that goal. 

00:11:59 Emily: Yes. Understanding that one thing does not necessarily equal the other. 

00:12:05 Hallie: And how do you determine… like you determine during those play situations, whether it’s a sensory need, a motor planning need, an emotional regulation need or like, you know, executive functioning, like how would you determine which need is it?

00:12:18 Emily: It takes time and it takes collaboration with the whole team. There are signs of sensory dysregulation, but they also can look very similar to emotional dysregulation. So it’s about understanding the child, talking with the parents, right? Parents, caregivers, family. It takes the whole team to figure out exactly what the needs are. And also we can also talk to the child a lot of the time, right? Depending on the child’s support needs, ask them what’s going on. You know, how are you feeling in this moment? Do you feel a lot of energy in your body? Do we need to jump? Do we need to squeeze something? But yes, I want to circle back to collaborating with an occupational therapist. If you’re [inaudible] or collaborating with the family is really important and it just takes time to understand the needs.

00:13:16 Hallie: It really is a team approach and also I loved working in a school because everyone was there, but you know, even as a private practice owner, SLP, you can still get access to those people. You can ask whether or not they’re in your practice itself. You can ask the parent, you know who they’re speaking with and working with and collaborate with them as well.

00:13:34 Emily: Yes, exactly.

00:13:36 Hallie: I want to touch upon how working on following directions could unintentionally teach overcompliance. Like how can that happen?

00:13:44 Emily: Yes. And this is an important point to touch on because and circling back to compliance based therapy, a lot of times if that is the focus of a child’s therapy for many years, right, following this direction will lead to the reward and that’s the cycle. Then often, it can lead to overcompliance and masking. So part of neurodiversity affirming therapy is not only understanding the individual’s differences, but fully accepting them and also celebrating them.

00:14:23 Emily: So we really want to just be really mindful of not having that be the focus of this child’s life. Let kids be kids and it’s really important to target self-advocacy and also instead of just requesting, protesting. Give the child the important skills to say when something doesn’t feel right or when they need support or when they just need to say no to something. So they’re not taught overcompliance. We want to give them autonomy and we want to teach self-advocacy.

00:15:01 Hallie: Can touch a little bit more on that? Like what is that exactly? Just so I’m not saying who might not be familiar with some of these terms.

00:15:07 Emily: Yes. So autonomy is the… pretty much and I like to have autonomy – is being able to do what you want to do. That’s it’s simplest definition. And that’s really important for neurodivergent people and just people in general, I think. And that can be stripped away from neurodivergent people unintentionally, right? And I want to say so many, if not all people working with kids, are well-intentioned. It’s just our training, our background that’s guiding these decisions. But when I learned about how important autonomy is, I keep that on the forefront of my mind.

00:15:47 Emily: And that goes, it’s especially important with bodily autonomy. So not moving or touching or physically, you know, changing positions without getting that consent, essentially, and making sure that they want to be touched or moved. And again, it’s nuanced. There are certain moments with safety where that’s not 100% possible, but you really want to… once I learned about it, I keep it front of mind. And self-advocacy is just ability and freedom to say when you need something, advocate for yourself. 

00:16:24 Hallie: You [inaudible] like, I don’t like that. Like, I don’t want to do that. I don’t like that. Like, something that I learned through this whole journey of even just like, especially with AAC, like hand over hand. I was like, oh my gosh, I’ve been around a time that I didn’t know. But again, like you said, once you know, you can do better and it’s learning. We’re all learning and being better.

00:16:46 Emily: Always. Always learning.

00:16:48 Hallie: I love that. So how is adult-directed, following direction tasks less motivating and meaningful than those childhood ones? Like, can you explain a little bit more of like what we typically think of following direction tasks to what we really should be doing instead. I know we touched on it earlier, but [inaudible] for what it might look like in therapy.

00:17:07 Emily: So it kind of ties back to like, kids be kids and adult directed tasks are, just like you said, they’re less motivating. I like to say that when I was a student myself, I can actually remember the teachers and professors who made learning fun. And we as humans, not only kids, learn better when we’re having fun, when we’re interested. And that’s just a fact. And it can be so much more powerful to teach a child skills or concepts when they’re motivating, intrinsically motivating. It can just be a magical shift, right? Like instead of sitting at the desk with me, quietly and working on a sheet that has these various shapes and well, you know, following directions.

00:18:03 Hallie: [inaudible]. like seashell on the beach, whatever might be. 

00:18:09 Emily: [inaudible]. We can pull in their interests and make it intrinsically motivating. And that’s where such great learning happens. 

00:18:17 Hallie: [inaudible]. Like even taking like a puppet pig and putting him in the various places if that’s what they’re into instead of like a worksheet or…

00:18:23 Emily: A small shift. Yes, they could be their favorite character and we’re practicing with a favorite character and that can just change the whole session and the relationship. 

00:18:35 Hallie: Another area I want to touch upon because as we’re talking about [inaudible] and neurodivergent children, how can following direction activities work with some of those PDAs profile students? Explain what that is and how those demands can affect them even more.

00:18:50 Emily: Yes, so PDA and this can be a whole separate…

00:18:54 Hallie: I’d want to touch upon it, you know, so I think it’s important to discuss [inaudible].

00:18:58 Emily: It’s not a fully recognized diagnosis in the U.S., but it is widely recognized in the U.K. And it is what I like to call in a neurodiversity affirming way, persistent drive for autonomy, but it’s also demand avoidance. And what we’re learning in these individuals with this profile is that demands can actually cause a nervous system shift that can spark a fight, flight, fawn, freeze response in their body. And we’re learning more about it, but that’s just what I’ll say. 

00:19:38 Emily: And so if individual or child student is demonstrating some of that, right? Like a demand is placed and a shutdown happens, it’s important to try to understand it. Maybe research PDA profiles because they do experience demands differently. And with these individuals, there’s actually a lot of great free information and pamphlets online. I think PDA Society is the one that I go to often. And with these – look at these scales, we can still, where we’re not eliminating all boundaries and all directions, you can guide them in a way that feels safer. 

00:20:19 Emily: So, an important distinction with these kids is they’re not not following the direction because they don’t want to, it’s because they can’t. It’s a whole body response to demand. So by reframing these demands, making them more open ended, we can help support them. So instead of put on your shoes, oh my gosh, it’s almost time for school. I wonder what we need to do or you know, even more directly, it’s hot out there. The pavement looks hot. What can you [inaudible] and you kind of guide them by giving them autonomy control in, you know, certain situations where it’s possible.

00:20:59 Hallie: Thank you. I think it was important since we were talking about neurodivergent children and talking about demand therapy and teaching how to respond to demands. I think it’s important that we just touch on that. Any last piece of advice would you give to someone who is just feeling a little overwhelmed on how to work on this skill with their students, maybe parents are asking for it, teachers are asking for it, and are just feeling a little overwhelmed.

00:21:23 Emily: Yeah. Last piece of advice I would give is, and I feel overwhelmed often with all of these changes and all of these new things that are important to be learning, is start with one small change. We can’t learn it all or do it all, all at once. But if we can make these little shifts here and there, that will add up and we can only… And give yourselves grace and credit for even making the effort to make these little changes. But if we can make little changes here and there, learn the child’s interests, learn what’s important and meaningful to them, then that’s really the most important thing we can do.

00:22:06 Hallie: Thank you so so much, Emily. Where could everyone learn more about you and everything you have to offer?

00:22:11 Emily: Yes. So I am on Instagram @ndaffirmingslp. I have a website ndaffirmingslp.com. And if you go to my resources page, there are a lot of free resources actually with these definitions and goals. And if you’d like to work with me in Los Angeles or California, you can find me at boundlessspeech.com.

00:22:34 Hallie: Thank you so so much. I always end my episodes with a joke since jokes build rapport and are very language based. So why couldn’t the duck pay for dinner?

00:22:44 Emily: Oh, my goodness. Something quack.

00:22:47 Hallie: No, but good guess. Her bill was too big.

00:22:51 Emily: Oh, that was a good one. I love that.

00:22:56 Hallie: Ba-dum-ching, guys. You can steal it, use it with your students, take credit for it. I didn’t write it. I found it on Google, guys. And thank you, Emily. Go check out on Instagram. Go check out her resources. Thank you so much for sharing your passion, your expertise with all of us. I know I learned a lot here today. I know that everyone listening got a lot of value add as well. And every Monday is a brand new episode, guys. So stay tuned to next week. And thank you, Emily, once again. And everyone stay out of trouble.

00:23:27 Hallie: Thanks so much for tuning in to another episode of SLP Coffee Talk. It means the world to me that you’re tuning in each and every week and getting the jolt of inspiration you need. You can find all of the links and information mentioned in this episode at my website, speechtimefun.com. Don’t forget to follow the show so you don’t miss any future episodes. And while you’re there, it would mean the world to me if you would take a few seconds and leave me an honest review. See you next week with another episode full of fun and inspiration from one SLP to another. Have fun guys!

Similar Posts